Speculative philosophy and the art of dramatization isabelle stengers philosophy as creation philosophy, wrote whitehead, never reverts to its old position a. The basic question is to decide whether or not empiricism can be renewed so that what is given in experience is not simplified too. The reader is indeed thinking with whitehead as if he was in his living room along with isabelle stengers. Not fifteen years ago, his speculative metaphysics stood at the margins of contemporary thought, dismissed as a baroque exercise in an outworn philosophical. Speculative philosophy and the art of dramatization. Taking a cue from isabelle stengers recent work in which she posits the notion of ecologies of practice, on the one hand, and whiteheads concept of concern, on the other, the paper argues. Though tensions exist between the philosophies of simondon and whitehead, they also resonate strongly. Full text of isabelle stengers thinking with whitehead. Some readers might conclude from this that the rise of newtoni anism was neither abrupt nor revolutionary. Declining performativity butler, whitehead and ecologies of. Merging, splitting and creating pdf files with powershell. This essay treats a selection of these newer gaian figures, specifically, isabelle stengerss gaia the intruder and bruno latours secular gaia, in relation to lovelocks gaia and lynn marguliss evocations of autopoietic gaia.
Stengers contrasts deleuzes celebration of unhinged creativity with whitehead s tremendous respect for the lessons of history and continual emphasis upon the importance of acquiring new habits in a way that is sensitive to the habitat these habits depend upon. A selection from the introduction to thinking whitehead will allow the group to consider how stengers herself came to use whitehead s method of questioning to explore issues in contemporary science most notably how to confront the insistence that science is valuefree in an age in which technology built on science threatens the. I argue that this has led to a general but illconceived. Whiteheads most extensive discussion of this bifurcation is his theories of the bifurcation of nature, in the concept of nature 1920. A constructivist reading of process and reality isabelle stengers. Her last book published in english is thinking with whitehead. If the title of todays blog post isnt giving it up yet, i wanted to share a powershell module called pswritepdf that can help you create and modify splitmerge pdf documents. Do those diagnosed with alzheimers disease lose their.
Were in the last days of 2019, and this will be my last blog post this year. Stengers 2010 physics has itself been reduced to a certain kind of physics, the triumph of the physics of laws over the physics of phenomena p. The product of thirty years engagement with the mathematician. Radio je na polju logicke, matematicke i filozofske nauke, te metafizike. First, i use the work of stengers to trace the complex and, occasionally, contradictory ways in which the concept of entropy was developed within physics in the 19th and 20th century. A free and wild creation of concepts isabelle stengers, michael chase, bruno latour alfred north whitehead has never gone out of print, but for a time he was decidedly out of fashion in the englishspeaking world. Cc byncsa link to publication record in explore bristol research pdf document this is the final published version of the article version of record.
Google scholar stengers i 201011 cosmopolitics iii, 2 vols, trans. If that work is an overview to whitehead s thinking, this short essay might be. Moreover, intellectually serious extrascientific figures of gaia have also been on the rise in the last decade. Isabelle stengers work on whitehead was a long time in the making as a work on whiteheads work, as an outcome of her thinking with whitehead through different instantiations of her own writing, and as a process of translation from the french original. This constructivist stance enables stengers to pursue her deleuzian inspired thinking with whitehead in relation to some of the most important abstractions of philosophical and scientific thought just as it enables alliez to find in deleuzewhitehead a new transcendental philo. But contrary to the rather cavalier way in which whitehead treats his own predecessors, stengers is very precise and follows with great at tention whiteheads own hunches. The reason for the secrecy of this school is itself something of a mystery. Isabelle stengers work on whitehead was a long time in the making as a work on whitehead s work, as an outcome of her thinking with. In its next session on tuesday, may 21, the camden philosophical society will build on its recent exploration of the writings of three french philosophers, who used the process philosophy of alfred north whitehead as a base to explore social and political issues, by reading belgian philosopher of science isabelle stengers. Thanks to liz mcfall for helping me thinking through the role of possession in constituting market relations, which she does primarily via the work of gabriel tarde rather than whitehead.
Analytical critiques of whitehead s metaphysics volume 2 issue 3 leemon b. Both found their philosophies on relational ontologies, emphasizing the relations between. Was it necessary to make the situation i was discussing actual in order to address readers for whom what mattered, what they were in the process of living. Whiteheads most daring concepts on new materials and in new exam ples. May 21, 2019 the camden public library of camden maine. An ontologyofthevirtual in whitehead smetaphysics keith robinson, university ofsouth dakota a good deal of recent work on deleuze has focused on his importance as a philosopher ofthe virtual and the intensive processes that emerge. The book is lively, deep, well researched and a jewel for philosophical writing. Stengers has written books on chaos theory with ilya prigogine, the russianbelgian physical chemist and nobel laureate noted for his work on dissipative structures, complex systems, and irreversibility, especially order out of chaos and the end of certainty. In a splendid work that serves as both introduction and erudite commentary, isabelle stengersaeone of todayaetms leading philosophers of scienceaegoes straight to the beating heart of whiteheadaetms thought. In this piece of writing he gives his analysis of the covid pandemic, its effect on the economy, what it reveals about labor and the necessity of the economy, and how such a situation can be used to reduce or abolish wage labor. Publishers pdf, also known as version of record license if available.
Both an erudite yet accessible introduction and a highly advanced commentary, it establishes the mathematicianphilosopher as a daring thinker on par with deleuze, guattari, and foucault. In collaboration with bertrand russell, he coauthored the threevolume principia mathematica 1910, 1912, 19. But contrary to the rather cavalier way in which whitehead treats his own predecessors, stengers is very precise and follows with great at tention whitehead s own hunches. Stengers point out the continuity of newtons ideas with al chemy and religious notions of even earlier vintage. In this paper, i argue that we need to rethink how we conceive of death as inevitable. And after, thinking from philosophers of creative thought, such as gilles deleuze and alfred north whitehead, together with that of scholars from science and technology studies, has been employed to propose a revised notion of document representation that does not rely upon representationalist understandings of science. It is a critical thinking supplement to any textbook or course. For the world, not of the world for the world, not of the world gabrys, jennifer 20140319 00. Are the impending system wide failures due to immense error, calculated strategy.
Introduction speculative metaphysics have recently reentered conversations among the philosophical avantgarde, and in this revival the philosophy of alfred north. Gaskill and adam nocek, minnesota up each one as she may. The relationship between laws and phenomena is an important one for cosmopolitics. Yet, to my mind, the newtonian breakthrough should not be seen as a linear outgrowth of these earlier ideas. What makes stengerss book, penser avec whiteheadin english, to think with. Ontological politics, ecology, and the anthroposcene. Isabelle stengers teaches philosophy of science at the free university of brussels. The whole book turns around the most arduous question of whitehead, without making any attempt either to avoid the difficulties or to obfuscate his philosophy by bringing in new irrelevant conundrums. And here the manner of theoretical characterization stengers, 2008, p. Meyer department of english washington university 9 n. Hume iain hamilton grant imagination isabelle stengers jakob bohme james hillman jean gebser john keats kant. Comparison always entails the risk of reducing philosophical thoughts to a matter of opinions to be compared from an outside, apparently neutral, standpoint, that is by an unmoved reader, and this risk becomes lethal when, as is the case with both whitehead and deleuze, the philosophers explicitly define their own enterprise as challenging any.
Jan, 2019 amaryl lids to download pdf you need some things, like my website and the name of the file. Ive just finished drafting this article, which will hopefully be featured in a special issue of the journal of philosophy, theology, and the sciences focused. And finally you may ask physicists, thinking that they should know since the name of their science, physics, is. Isabelle stengers thinking with whitehead foreword. Here is a pdf of the final draft accepted for publication under the revised title the varieties of physicalist ontology. In this article, i use the work of alfred north whitehead and isabelle stengers to challenge the biomedical and commonsense view that those diagnosed with alzheimers disease suffer an irreparable and inevitable loss of self and that this loss is inextricably tied to a decline in linguistic capability which itself bears immediate witness to a deterioration in the brain. In thinking with whitehead, isabelle stengers one of todays leading philosophers of science goes straight to the beating heart of alfred north whiteheads thought.
At its inception innocent of philosophical or metaphysical designs, the gaia hypothesis of james lovelock and lynn margulis was soon liberated from the precincts of scientific cultivation to enter. Rather than saying that there are no physical lawsan untenable positionstengers. A free and wild creation of concepts cambridge, ma. A study in whiteheads processrelational alternative. This also demands a process of eternal vigilance for the relevance of learning practices that may seem irrelevant to pedagogical frameworks. Datasets available include lcsh, bibframe, lc name authorities, lc classification, marc codes, premis vocabularies, iso language codes, and more. Read do those diagnosed with alzheimers disease lose their souls.
Analytical critiques of whiteheads metaphysics journal. Whitehead isabelle stengers 2011 thinking with whitehead. When we speak about nature, it may be about our environment as we can experience it, the trees along a river, with flowers and birds. Whitehead s concern for the creative advance into novelty is related to learning processes as a coming into existence and the pedagogical work of developing a nurturing context. Najbolje je poznat po svome radu na principa matematica koju je napisao u suradnji s bertrandom russellom. For pignarre and stengers, at its most basic, capitalism is a social system which depoliticises decision. Pedagogy without bodies as a concept alludes to the incorporeal and material composition of sense which, i believe, is an important orientation for thinking philosophy of education, and curriculum in terms of dispersed, intensive and inhuman forces and processes intricate to any singular pedagogical event and its readability.
In a splendid work that serves as both introduction and erudite commentary, isabelle stengers one of todays leading philosophers of sciencegoes straight to the beating heart of whitehead s thought. Full text of isabelle stengers thinking with whitehead foreword. Latour is quite interested, also, in isabelle stengers discussion of whitehead, as he makes clear here. Notes in how to do things with sensors on manifold. New post fulltext search for articles, highlighting downloaded books, view pdf in a browser and download history correction in our blog.
This discussion picks up where my related earlier text, program earth, left off in thinking about propositions for open technology which are somewhat different expressions of openness than those that call for open hardware, software, and dataas this openness requires an attention to the milieus that inform technology as an expanded field of relations. We use cookies to offer you a better experience, personalize content, tailor advertising, provide social media features, and better understand the use of our services. However, as stengers notes in her introduction to thinking with whitehead, this situation is changing, and whiteheads influence can now be. The whole book turns around the most arduous question of whitehead. Leibniz and the baroque where whitehead makes a surprising and crucial appearance, deleuze chooses to introduce the english mathematician and philosopher as the successor, or diadoche, of what he describes as a somewhat secret school. In thinking with whitehead, isabelle stengers one of todays leading philosophers of science goes straight to the beating heart of alfred. Ontological politics, ecology, and the anthroposcene adrian ivakhiv 4 and relations, which is the world in the process of being made, of being woven into fabrics of relational force and counterforce, networks, systems, webs.
Ris procite, reference manager, endnote, bibtex, medlars, refworks. It is best used in conjunction with the analytic thinking guide. In one sense, then, stengers book signals a return to whitehead in the midst of a newly emerging epoch in human history marked by globalization, climate change, mass species extinction, and the emergence of the anthropocene. Alfred north whitehead has never gone out of print, but for a time he was decidedly out of fashion in the englishspeaking world. May 09, 2019 isabelle stengers thinking with whitehead pdf her masters thesis constituted an analysis of the integration of indigenous medical assistants ami within the health care department of the belgian congo between and africa is the premier journal devoted to the study of african societies drooit culture. This includes data values and the controlled vocabularies that house them. Isabelle stengers has produced a wideranging survey of whitehead s ideas in her work thinking with whitehead. What better way to end a good year than with the release of the new powershell module. Pdf thinking with whitehead and stengers ronald desmet. Thinking with whitehead isabelle stengers harvard university.
604 471 1219 681 332 468 1355 718 490 1266 19 194 1623 1106 1125 308 1513 359 754 749 937 337 493 236 803 1605 1341 295 1203 1473 920 497 1598 1561 772 1458 793 178 1096 861 208 1097 899 12